Yeti Rambler vs. Stanley Quencher: Which Travel Mug Is the King of the Cupholder?

WHETHER YOU’RE A caffeine fiend, a die-hard hydrationist, or someone who just needs a beverage to sip throughout the day, most of us can’t bear to be without a drink on hand for more than a few hours. That’s where all-day travel mugs like the Stanley Quencher H2.0 Flowstate Tumbler and Yeti Rambler Straw Mug come in.

The Yeti Rambler Straw Mug and Stanley Quencher H2.0 Flowstate Tumbler are oversized, vacuum-insulated, stainless steel travel mugs designed to hold at least 40 ounces of your favorite beverage. They’ll keep hot drinks (like coffee, tea, and cider) piping hot or cold bevies chilled for hours. Both are large yet portable enough with tapered bottoms designed to play well with most standard cupholders, so you can take them almost anywhere. Also, these do have straws and holes in their lids for them. This means they are not in fact leakproof.

These travel mugs exploded in popularity thanks to TikTok and social media over the past couple of years, causing stampedes in Targets and clamoring from thirsty fans (sorry, not sorry). So I decided to take both for a spin over a month to see how they stack up against each other (and whether they’re easier than a standard water bottle or even a smart water bottle). I obsessively lugged them everywhere I went—to the park, to the zoo, to the gym, on every car ride, and used them extensively at my WFH desk. Here’s what I think about each and my experience with them.

Size and Capacity

At roughly 5.25-inches wide (at the widest part) by 12.3-inches tall, the Stanley Tumbler is slightly taller than the Yeti Rambler. That may not seem like much, but a one-foot-tall mug makes its presence known in the cupholder of my 4Runner. It’s tall enough to border on obtrusive, and I can’t imagine using a mug that’s even slightly larger.

Because of the 1.4-pound empty weight, I found it best to use with the straw. Ditching the straw and sipping directly from the lid, especially with the mug filled to the brim, feels heavy and cumbersome. But I do like the fact that the tapered 3.1-inch-wide bottom fits easily into most standard cupholders (that includes cars, treadmills, and most gym equipment, too).

Look and Feel

The Flowstate Tumbler is available in over 30 colors, including basics like white and black and more extreme options like neon green and tigerlily plum. With a smooth powder-coated finish, the Rambler feels vaguely premium (as much as a stainless steel travel mug can, anyway). It looks great and feels ergonomic to hold. The handle is made of a slightly textured, almost rubbery plastic that feels comfortable in the hand while providing a little extra grip. It’s also oversized just enough to accommodate larger hands or gloved hands, which I found helpful as the winter weather here in New England demands.

Temperature Control

Double-wall vacuum insulation is the secret sauce to keeping your favorite beverages at the right temperature. In my testing, I found that the Stanley just barely ekes out the win in a temperature control test. After filling my mug with a piping hot Americano around 9 a.m., I found that the temperature had dropped by just under 30°F by mid-afternoon, about six hours later. For WFH-ers or drivers who spend long hours on the road, this mug will keep your morning coffee plenty hot for the better part of your workday.

I also tested the Tumbler’s “chill-retention” capabilities by filling it with ice-cold water at the beginning of my workday and leaving it overnight. The temperature only rose by two degrees in about 24 hours. Bonus: The vacuum-insulated design also maintains the tumbler’s exterior at a constant temperature, so you never have to worry about scalding your hands or condensation.

Leakage

The Tumbler’s screw-on lid does an admirable job of keeping beverages contained. On typical daily drives or while carrying it on several walks around town, it never leaked, even while the liquids inside splashed around. It’s not, however, leakproof. Tipped on its side, the Tumber will leak, so it’s best to ensure you’re keeping it upright when full.

Ease of Cleaning

Stanley’s FlowState lid is a 3-in-1 design, allowing you sip, straw, or drink your bevies directly from the tumbler with the lid off. It’s great in theory, but I found the two-piece construction harder to clean. It requires removing the clip-in plastic swivel from the lid itself and thoroughly washing both parts. There are plenty of crevices for mold or water to stick around if not cleaned properly.

On the plus side, the entire tumbler is dishwasher-safe. Even after repeated uses and cleanings, however, I never noticed any “off” smell or discoloration of the tumbler’s stainless steel lining. We should note that earlier this year it was reported that Stanley uses some lead in its vacuum-insulation process. This is inaccessible to consumers in the basecap, but we wanted to note it nonetheless.

Who It’s Best for

The Stanley Quencher H2.0 Flowstate Tumbler is similar in almost every respect to the Yeti Rambler Straw Mug. It does outshine the latter in two respects. First, the handle is larger and easier to hold—both great features if you have bigger hands or plan to use the mug in the winter when you might be wearing gloves.

Second, it edges out the Yeti with slightly better temperature control. So, if that’s especially important to you, the Flowstate Tumbler is probably for you.

Size and Capacity

At 10.8 inches tall (without the straw), it’s about 1.5 inches shorter than the Stanley Tumbler. That may not seem like much, but I much enjoyed the more compact size. When filled with liquids, it’s the easiest of the two mugs to handle, and the Yeti felt a lot less noticeable in my truck’s cupholder. At 1.7 pounds, it is slightly heavier by almost half a pound—a surprising amount of heft for an empty mug. But the overall proportions make it easier to wrangle.

Look and Feel

The Yeti’s double-wall, vacuum-insulated design means the outside always feels about the same as the ambient temperature in your office, car, or gym. There’s no indication of whether the beverage inside is boiling water or ice-cold seltzer. The stainless steel construction of the mug itself feels like a well-made, premium product—not surprising given Yeti’s history of designing over-the-top coolers. The handle is slightly more compact than the Rambler’s. It’s a design I prefer, as I like to hold a mug like this directly by the handle rather than wrapping my fingers around the mug through the handle.

Temperature Control

In my most unscientific head-to-head comparison, both the Stanley and Yeti models kept hot drinks hot and cold drinks cold for almost exactly the same amount of time. For real-world purposes, expect to get a full workday (at least six hours) out of your hot morning coffee if you happen to be a slow-sippin’ kind of person. Cold beverages will stay chilled for a full day, especially with the addition of ice.

Leakage

During my daily use, I found that the well-fitting rubber gasket in the lid kept the contents contained as long as the mug was upright. Tipped over on its side, it will leak, albeit slowly. Still, you’ll want to ensure you keep yours properly secured in your hand or cupholder. Do keep in mind that both of these mugs are not intended to be fully leakproof (they do have straws).

Ease of Cleaning

The Yeti Rambler stands out for how easy it is to clean. The three-part design—including the mug itself, the clear lid, and the plastic straw—couldn’t be simpler. Without unnecessary crevices for water and mold to hide, it’s super easy to hand-wash and air-dry. Alternatively, every part is 100% dishwasher-safe. This is the typical ease-of-cleaning experience we’ve had with nearly every Yeti mug or bottle we’ve used.

Who It’s Best for

Drinkers who prefer travel mugs with a squatter, shorter design will appreciate the Rambler’s specs. It’s slightly wider than the Stanley option but short enough not to feel like it’s getting in the way during your morning commute. If you hand-wash your dishes, you’ll no doubt like the simpler, one-piece design of the Yeti’s lid as well. Lastly, if you, like me, prefer to hold your mugs by the handle, the Rambler might be the one for you.

Both travel mugs are very similar, so which is better is a matter of personal preference. The Stanley Tumbler offers an easier-to-hold handle and maintains its temperature slightly better. But it is taller, making it a bit more cumbersome to hold and drink from. I’m also not a fan of the lid, which feels clever but unnecessarily complicated, making it harder to clean.

The Yeti, on the other hand, has better overall proportions that make it easier to use every day. However, some people might find the handle undersized and harder to hold, especially with gloved hands. It is the easiest of the two mugs to clean, though, and that’s a key difference in my book.

Best Duffel Bags | Best Carry-On Luggage | Best MagSafe Wallets | Best Travel Blazers | Best Travel Bags | 2024 Men’s Health Travel Awards | Best Luggage Brands | Best Dopp Kits | Best Luggage Sets | Best AirTag Wallets | Best Travel Pants | Best Travel Backpacks | Best Backpacks