UTI Guideline Offers Clarity, Reveals Gaps

New recommendations from the WikiGuidelines Group offer strategies for the prevention, diagnosis, and management of urinary tract infections (UTIs) in children and adults.

While the guideline covers a range of clinical topics, including prophylaxis and antimicrobial stewardship, many key clinical questions remain unanswered due to a lack of high-quality evidence, according to lead author Zachary Nelson, PharmD, MPH, of HealthPartners and Park Nicollet Health Services, St. Louis Park, Minnesota, and colleagues.

“This guideline fills a critical gap by providing pragmatic, broadly applicable recommendations tailored for generalist care and systems-based practice,” Nelson and colleagues wrote in JAMA Network Open. “Our guidance is rooted in the best available evidence and is designed for clinicians from various backgrounds and healthcare environments. It emphasizes a patient-centered approach to the diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of UTIs and related genitourinary infections.”

The guideline panelists, including 54 experts from 12 countries, developed the document in accordance with Standards for Quality Improvement Reporting Excellence and the WikiGuidelines charter. The latter requires that “clear recommendations” are based on data from at least two concordant randomized clinical trials (RCTs), or one RCT plus one concordant prospective observational study.

This approach allowed the panel to provide clear recommendations for 6 out of 37 unique questions, while three other questions were partially answered. In other words, 75% of the questions lacked sufficient evidence for answers.

“These guidelines are important because they illuminate the clinical data and lack of data we have for approaching diagnosis and treatment of this common infection that leads to a wide array of morbidity and sometimes mortality, as well as significant cost burden to the healthcare system,” said Co-author Sarah Kurz, MD, clinical assistant professor of internal medicine at Michigan Medicine, Ann Arbor, Michigan, in a written comment.

Jessica Hammett, MD, a urologist at Emory Healthcare, Atlanta, who was not an author of the study, suggested that the guideline is additionally impactful because of the panel’s geographic diversity.

“It is an international collaboration that takes into account regional and international practice patterns and differences,” Hammett said in a written comment.

The key guideline recommendations are briefly summarized below.

Preventive Strategies for UTI

The guideline endorses cranberry products as preventive for UTI-prone women, children, and post-intervention patients, though data are insufficient to recommend them for older adults, those with bladder issues, or pregnant women.

Topical estrogen is recommended for postmenopausal women with recurrent UTIs, as it helps restore the vaginal microbiome with minimal systemic absorption. It may also benefit patients with breast cancer when nonhormonal alternatives fail.

For those with intact bladder anatomy, methenamine hippurate is suggested as a noninferior alternative to low-dose antibiotics for preventing recurrent UTIs.

“These findings confirm the best practice of starting postmenopausal women on vaginal estrogen to prevent UTIs, which is a treatment option that should be implemented more commonly,” Hammett said. “Interestingly as compared to the AUA guidelines, this paper recommends the use of cranberry supplementation and methenamine as antibiotic alternatives for preventing UTIs.”

Empirical Treatment Recommendations

According to the guideline, empirical treatment for UTIs should focus on antimicrobials with high urinary tract concentration and local pathogen efficacy.

Nitrofurantoin is recommended for uncomplicated cystitis, while trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole (TMP/SMX) and first-generation cephalosporins are advised for pyelonephritis.

For intravenous therapy, ceftriaxone is preferred unless there are risk factors for multidrug resistance.

Recommended treatment durations include 5 days for nitrofurantoin, 3 days for TMP/SMX and fluoroquinolones, and a single dose for fosfomycin in acute cystitis cases. For acute pyelonephritis, fluoroquinolones are advised for 5-7 days, with dose-optimized beta-lactams for 7 days. Gram-negative bacteremia from urinary sources warrants a 7-day course.

Stewardship and Clinical Management

The guideline emphasizes antimicrobial stewardship, with support for antibiotic de-escalation and oral regimens where feasible, to reduce adverse effects and hospital stays. Although evidence is limited, the authors suggest thorough allergy assessment and selective reporting of susceptibility results to enhance antibiotic selection.

While data were insufficient to make clear recommendations about the treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria, Nelson and colleagues suggested that this practice “risks side effects without benefit” while threatening antimicrobial sustainability.

Hammett agreed, noting that “[this] serves as an important reminder not to treat asymptomatic bacteriuria, as it increases side effects and bacterial resistance without any improvement as compared to placebo.”

Special Considerations for Urologic Procedures

Finally, patients undergoing urologic procedures, routine cystoscopy, and urodynamic studies generally do not require prophylactic antibiotics, according to the guideline. Single-dose antibiotic prophylaxis is recommended for low-risk nephrolithotomy patients, though high-risk individuals, such as those who are pregnant or post-kidney transplant, may require extended prophylaxis.

Co-author Kurz suggested that the guideline consolidates and supports the foundation of evidence driving common practices.

“I don’t think these guidelines offer any strikingly new strategies, which is unsurprising, as they were created after a deep dive into existing literature,” Kurz said. “But more importantly, what I think they do is to highlight where and what the evidence is for many of the clinical strategies that are commonly employed. For example, in terms of prevention, it is common for primary care physicians, urologists, and infectious diseases doctors to recommend cranberry and hydration and to use methenamine. These guidelines highlight that there is sufficient quality and quantity of evidence to support these interventions.”

She also noted how the guidelines emphasize the need for symptoms to make a UTI diagnosis and advise against routine testing of asymptomatic individuals.

“Despite this not being new information, typical clinical practice is often out of step here, and this [guideline] reemphasizes the important factors when considering UTI diagnosis,” Kurz said.

Finally, she expressed frustration for the numerous knowledge gaps remaining in this area, which may be traced back to barriers ranging from the semantic to the more systemic.

“Some of the difficulty is lack of clear definitions and precise terminology regarding UTIs,” Kurz said, noting the unclear distinction between complicated and uncomplicated UTIs. “I would also argue that UTIs are a disease that predominantly affects women, and like many other diseases where this is the case, [they] tend to be less studied. Hopefully, this guideline’s spotlight on all that we do not know can inspire high-quality research to address these gaps, leading to optimal patient care along with decreased burden on the system as a whole in terms of cost and antimicrobial resistance.”

The study was funded by Merck. The WikiGuidelines Group that established this guideline is entirely voluntary and unpaid; the group intends to establish a nonprofit organization to support the development of other guidelines using this novel methodology and eventually intends to trademark the name WikiGuidelines. The authors discl