Hoka Speedgoat 6 vs. Skyline-Float X: Which Trail Shoe Reigns Supreme?
WHEN IT COMES to trail running and hiking footwear, Hoka has established itself as a leader in cushioning and support for any surface. Two of its standout models—the Speedgoat 6 and the Skyline-Float X—cater to different types of outdoor enthusiasts but share Hoka’s signature plush ride and durability. While both shoes are engineered for off-road
WHEN IT COMES to trail running and hiking footwear, Hoka has established itself as a leader in cushioning and support for any surface. Two of its standout models—the Speedgoat 6 and the Skyline-Float X—cater to different types of outdoor enthusiasts but share Hoka’s signature plush ride and durability. While both shoes are engineered for off-road adventures, each model has distinct strengths that make it more suitable for specific types of runners and hikers.
Hoka Speedgoat 6 vs. Skyline-Float X
We rallied the team of MH fitness editors and tested both shoes over various terrains, from rocky, technical trails to long, rolling dirt paths. Here’s an in-depth look at what each shoe offers and who each is best suited for.
Hoka Speedgoat 6: The Versatile Trail Running Workhorse
Specifications
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | 5 mm drop |
|---|---|
| Stack Height | 38 mm stack height |
| Weight | 9.8 oz |
The Speedgoat series has built a reputation for excelling in various trail conditions, and the latest iteration maintains that standard. The stack height remains unchanged from the Speedgoat 5, but Hoka has shaved off about half-an-ounce, making the shoe slightly lighter.
One of the most significant updates is the improved upper. MH Fitness and Commerce Editor Charles Thorp, NASM, found in his testing that, “As sturdy as the shoe is, the upper manages to be light and breathable, which helps keep the foot cool when you’re pushing the miles.”
Hoka has replaced the previous model’s stretchier material with a new textile woven upper that enhances the fit and reduces unwanted movement inside the shoe. The result? A more locked-in feel while still maintaining breathability. The midsole features a refined version of Hoka’s compressed EVA foam, which delivers reliable cushioning over long distances without feeling too soft.
MH Senior Fitness Editor Brett Williams, NASM, made a fair disclaimer for the weatherized version of the model. “It’s a solid general-use trail shoe for most types of runners, but make sure to wear thick socks for the GTX model,” he says. “I’ve experienced some toe rub.”
Who Should Consider the Speedgoat 6?
- Trail runners looking for a stable yet neutral ride.
- Long-distance runners who need durability and consistent support.
- Runners who prefer a cushioned shoe that doesn’t feel overly soft.
- Those seeking a reliable, all-around trail shoe at a reasonable price point.
Hoka Skyline-Float X: A Maximalist Take on Hiking Footwear
Specifications
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | 14.90 oz |
|---|---|
| Stack Height | 5mm drop |
| Weight | 39 mm heel stack height |
The Skyline-Float X is designed with hikers in mind, but its high-stack cushioning and responsive ride make it a potential crossover option for those looking to move quickly on the trails. “If you’re looking for maximum comfort for your off-road runs, then this is a great way to go … especially when you plan on rucking or backpacking,” says Thorp.
The first thing you notice about the Skyline-Float X is the sheer amount of foam underfoot—43mm in the heel, which is more than some of Hoka’s running shoes. Despite this, the shoe remains surprisingly stable thanks to including a Pebax midsole plate, which doubles as a rock plate for extra protection on rugged terrain.
The engineered air mesh upper offers exceptional comfort, but it has a downside: It retains moisture longer than desired, making it less ideal for wet conditions. Additionally, while the fit is secure through the midfoot and heel, the toe box tapers in a touch more than expected, which may be a drawback for hikers who prefer extra toe splay for downhill stability.
Who Should Consider the Skyline-Float X?
- Hikers who prioritize comfort and want a high-stacked shoe for long days on the trail.
- Speed hikers who appreciate a plush, responsive midsole.
- Backpackers looking for a stable shoe that can handle heavy loads.
- Those who value sustainability—this shoe incorporates plant-based materials to reduce its environmental impact.
Key Differences
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Get?
If you’re primarily a trail runner seeking a reliable, all-around performer, the Speedgoat 6 is the clear winner. It offers ample cushioning without compromising stability, making it ideal for new and experienced trail runners tackling varied terrain.
On the other hand, if you’re a hiker or backpacker looking for supreme comfort on long treks, the Skyline-Float X is a standout choice. Its thick midsole provides plush protection for your feet, though its heavier weight and tapered toe box may not suit everyone.
Ultimately, your decision should come down to your primary activity. Runners should go with the Speedgoat 6, while hikers who want next-level cushioning will appreciate the Skyline-Float X. Either way, Hoka delivers yet another round of well-crafted trail shoes that excel in their respective categories.
Specifications
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | 5 mm drop |
|---|---|
| Stack Height | 38 mm stack height |
| Weight | 9.8 oz |
Specifications
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | 14.90 oz |
|---|---|
| Stack Height | 5mm drop |
| Weight | 39 mm heel stack height |
More of Our Favorite Great Running Gear
Best Running Shoes for Men | Best Marathong Gear | Best Workout Clothes For Men | Best Headphones For Running | Tracksmith Eliot Racer Review | Most Cushioned Running Shoes | Best Neutral Running Shoes | Best Trail Running Shoes for Men | Best Workout Shoes for Men | Best Treadmill Running Shoes | Best Wide Toe Box Running Shoes | Best Minimalist Running Shoes | Best Long-Distance Running Shoes
Eric Sung, CSCS, is a New York City–based trainer and a member of MH’s Strength in Diversity Initiative.He specializes in athletic training and recently completed his first triathlon.
Charles Thorp is the Fitness and Commerce Editor at Men’s Health, where he shares the best product recommendations in gym equipment, recovery tools, supplements, and more. Following an early life in athletics, Charles became a NASM-certified trainer and began writing programs alongside the most respected coaches in the world.
Since entering the world of fitness content, Charles has had the opportunity to learn from and train alongside high performance individuals from the NFL, UFC, NBA, Formula 1, CrossFit, US Olympics, and Navy SEALs. When he’s not writing about training programs or gear, he can be seen at the gym or in the wild, putting them to the test.
About Author
